FPI’s strategy for 2020: Cautious on fiscal math amid fears a rating downgrade

R Basil

Q. Data shows foreign investors have turned net sellers for India’s sovereign bonds during the last four months. What do you think is the reason?

A: It is because of the flattening of inflation expectations; currently food prices have been constituting a key concern and so has the potential impact of globally elevated oil prices, which is driving domestic inflation. I think this situation is fluid, and you may see a reversal based on views on these subjects evolving over the next few weeks.

Q. Do we see this outflow trend reversing or the sentiment changing any time soon?

A: It is more of a wait-and-watch situation as foreign investors’ concerns are not addressed by regulators and the Government of India in Union Budget 2020. If authorities take enough measures, such as pushing the issuance of dollar and masala bonds by Indian companies or issuing offshore sovereign bonds themselves, we may see flows coming back to India.

Q. Due to the US-Iran conflicts or Coronavirus outbreak in China, do we see such geopolitical and health tensions indicate more fund outflows from or a halt of fresh inflows into India?

A: No. I do not believe they will stop, but they will surely be recalibrated. India is not treated as a ‘safe haven’ and flows at such uncertain times are into safe havens. That explains the buoyancy of the USD and US equity markets.

Q. What other issues concern FPIs currently when it comes to investing in Indian markets?

A: Transaction costs, the eclectic and segregated settlement mechanism leading to transaction delays and limited liquidity in the credit space are ongoing concerns, along with withholding taxes. The major concern, however, stays intact. It is the Indian fiscal arithmetic not matching estimations provided by the government, thus inviting headwinds of rating agencies probably by late-2020.

Q. What is your take on Union Budget 2020?

A: It was a non-event budget as revisions made in a bid to attract foreign flows are not adequately thought of. Thus, nothing significant, but optical projections of reigning in the fiscal numbers, is yet to be witnessed. The Indian fiscal situation is precarious, and I do not see it change unless India chooses to borrow handsomely in INR from overseas.

Q. Market reports are talking about relaxing the norms for Indian companies to borrow from the offshore market, thus boosting foreign flows. What are your thoughts about the development?

A: You will hear bits and pieces – nothing structural – and that is a constant frustration and disappointment for international observers and stakeholders like myself.

Q. Which sector/segment would you see as an attractive investment opportunity in the current slowdown scenario?

A: High-grade and mid-tier credits from the infrastructure, manufacturing and financial services space

Q. What would your 2020 investment advice/strategy be for India?

A: The prevailing Indian economic picture warrants offshore observer or advisor from being cautiously optimistic for now as various things, including headwinds from global rating agencies, fiscal stance and economic growth in the nation, are considered. Imminent measures and data on the nation’s economic and fundamental trends will give better clarity to global investors over India’s standpoint.


All opinions expressed by the Participants are solely their current opinions and do not reflect the opinions of Brickwork Ratings (BWR) and its associates and/or affiliates or the companies with which the Participants are affiliated, and may have been previously disseminated by them. The Participants’ opinions are based upon information they consider reliable, but neither BWR nor its affiliates, nor the companies with which such participants are affiliated, warrant its completeness or accuracy, and it should not be relied upon as such.

The Participants may be actively involved in securities trading discussed in the interview/content, on behalf of themselves, their companies and their clients. Also, the Participants and/or their companies engage in securities trading and may hold both long and short options and/or futures positions in the same security, as well as the underlying stock. The opinions expressed by the Participants may be short-term in nature and are subject to change.

Any views expressed is NOT a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security and/or investments. BWR has no responsibility for any liability arising out of the views expressed here to any parties.