Skip to main content

Rating Withdrawal Policy

November 2026

Facilities and instruments rated remain under continuous surveillance throughout their lifecycle. Those with scheduled repayment dates (such as term loans or bonds) cease to exist upon maturity, redemption, or prepayment, and ratings are typically withdrawn once these events occur. Independent written confirmation from banks, lenders, debenture trustees, auditors, or other independent sources is required to confirm full repayment. Ratings may also be withdrawn at the written request of the issuer or borrower while facilities or instruments remain active, subject to specific conditions including lender approval.

To process a rating withdrawal request, the following submission requirements must be met:

  • Official written request and independent confirmation, specifically a No Objection Certificate (NOC) or No Dues Certificate (NDC), submitted on official letterhead bearing an authorized signature and seal, or via email from an official address.
  • Submission of all required withdrawal documentation to the rating team.
  • Full settlement of all pending dues and fees.

Additionally, the dissolution or cessation of legal existence of the issuer or borrower serves as a ground for rating withdrawal.

The procedure to be followed in respect of withdrawal of ratings is detailed below:

1. Withdrawal of ratings for fully redeemed securities

(NCDs, bonds, listed securities, or securities proposed to be listed on a recognized stock exchange)

  • Withdrawal of ratings for all NCDs/bonds (including listed securities / proposed to be listed securities on a recognized stock exchange) that are fully redeemed on the due date or prematurely should be processed upon receiving intimation of such redemption. Documents normally provided by the issuers as evidence of redemption include:
    • Written confirmation from the issuer stating that the instrument has been redeemed.
    • Public disclosure of redemption by the issuer on a public website (such as NSDL or stock exchanges).
    • Written confirmation from the investor(s) acknowledging receipt of full payment.
    • Written confirmation from the Debenture Trustee stating that the instrument is fully redeemed.
  • A written confirmation from the issuer or investor, alongside an NDC or redemption confirmation from the Debenture Trustee, are essential documents and cannot be dispensed with. Where there are multiple investors, a written confirmation from the Debenture Trustee attesting to the full redemption of the instrument(s) and confirming that no obligations remain against the rated securities is adequate.

2. Withdrawal of ratings for securities not fully redeemed

(NCDs, bonds, listed securities, or securities proposed to be listed on a recognized stock exchange)

Ratings for securities that are not fully redeemed may be withdrawn if the following conditions are met:

  • The instrument must have been continuously rated by BWR for at least 5 years or 50% of its contracted tenure, whichever is higher.
  • An alternate credit rating must be available for the instrument from another registered Credit Rating Agency (CRA).
  • A written request from the issuer for rating withdrawal, accompanied by an official undertaking confirming the availability of an alternate rating (subject to independent verification by the Rating Team).
  • Before finalizing the withdrawal, BWR will review the rating based on available information. The assigned rating (which may differ from the existing outstanding rating) will be published in the withdrawal rating rationale / press release.

3. Withdrawal of ratings for securities with multiple CRA ratings (not fully redeemed)

(NCDs, bonds, listed securities, or securities proposed to be listed on a recognized stock exchange)

In cases where multiple ratings are present on an instrument without a regulatory requirement for them, ratings for securities that are not fully redeemed may be withdrawn if the following conditions are met:

  • The instrument must have been continuously rated by BWR for at least 3 years or 50% of its contracted tenure, whichever is higher.
  • An NOC must be received from bondholders representing at least 75% of the outstanding debt by value approving the withdrawal.
  • An alternate credit rating must be available for the instrument from another registered CRA.
  • A written request from the issuer for rating withdrawal, accompanied by an official undertaking confirming the availability of an alternate rating (subject to independent verification by the Rating Team).
  • Before finalizing the withdrawal, BWR will review the rating based on available information. The assigned rating (which may differ from the existing outstanding rating) will be published in the withdrawal rating rationale / press release.

Note: In line with SEBI Circular SEBI/HO/DDHS/DDHS-POD2/P/CIR/2025/101 dated 11th July 2025 and earlier directions, while withdrawing the rating of listed or proposed-to-be-listed securities, a review shall be conducted based on available information and mentioned (even if different from the existing outstanding rating) in the rationale / press release for withdrawal.

4. Withdrawal of ratings for perpetual debt securities

(Listed or proposed to be listed on a recognized stock exchange)

Ratings for perpetual debt securities may be withdrawn if the following conditions are met:

  • The instrument must have been continuously rated by BWR for at least 5 years.
  • An alternate credit rating must be available for the instrument from another registered CRA.
  • A written request from the issuer for rating withdrawal, accompanied by an official undertaking confirming the availability of an alternate rating (subject to independent verification by the Rating Team).
  • Submission of an undertaking or a valid rating letter from the other CRA confirming that an alternate rating is active on the instrument.

5. Withdrawal of ratings for money market instruments

(Commercial papers, certificates of deposit, etc.)

Ratings for money market instruments may be withdrawn if no obligations remain outstanding against the rated instruments and the following conditions are met:

  • Written confirmation from the Issuing and Paying Agent (IPA) or Debenture Trustee (as applicable, depending on the nature of the instrument) confirming repayment.
  • Written confirmation from the issuer confirming redemption of the instrument.

Note: Both documents are mandatory for withdrawal of the rating.

6. Withdrawal of ratings for fixed deposits or public deposits

Ratings for fixed deposits or public deposits may be withdrawn under any of the following conditions:

  • Upon full redemption as per original terms, based on a written withdrawal request from the entity and a certificate from the auditor (for unsecured FDs) or trustee (for secured FDs) confirming all investors have been paid off.
  • Upon prepayment of all outstanding obligations directly to investors, based on a written withdrawal request from the entity and a certificate from the auditor (unsecured) or trustee (secured) confirming full repayment to all investors.
  • If the issuer sets aside adequate funds in an escrow account for principal and interest payments, the rating can be withdrawn upon a written request from the entity and submission of an auditor's certificate confirming fund adequacy. (BWR will review the rating based on available information and publish the assigned rating in the rationale / press release).
  • If the issuer submits a written request for withdrawal and confirms non-usage of the rating to raise fresh FDs, the rating will be placed on a Notice of Withdrawal for 3 months prior to withdrawal.
  • If the requirement for a rating is removed by statutory or regulatory action, the issuer must submit a written request along with documentary evidence of full regulatory compliance, alongside NOCs from at least 75% of FD investors by value. (BWR will review the rating based on available information and publish the assigned rating in the rationale / press release).
  • If the rated instrument remains in the default category (BWR D) for more than 3 years, it shall be placed on a Notice of Withdrawal for 3 months and withdrawn thereafter.

7. Withdrawal of ratings for bank loans or facilities

Ratings for bank loans or facilities (including entities currently in RNR or INC categories) may be withdrawn upon receipt of a written withdrawal request from the entity under any of the following conditions:

  • When rated facilities remain outstanding, upon receipt of an NOC for withdrawal from the client's bank(s):
    • For sole lender arrangements, an NOC from the sole bank/lender.
    • For consortium arrangements, NOCs from all lenders or from the lead bank certifying that NOC is given on behalf of all lenders of the Consortium.
    • For Multiple Banking Arrangements, NOCs/NDCs from all banks whose facilities are currently rated.
    • If NOCs/NDCs are received from only a few lenders, partial withdrawal will proceed exclusively for those specific facilities with valid NOCs/NDCs or where debt is fully extinguished, while remaining facilities with outstanding liabilities will continue to be maintained, monitored, and reviewed. (When withdrawing against an NOC where facilities remain outstanding, BWR will review the rating based on available information and publish the assigned rating in the press release / rationale).
  • When rated facilities have been fully repaid, upon receipt of an NDC from the banks, a written confirmation from the entity certifying full repayment along with a formal withdrawal request, and written confirmations from all lenders certifying full liquidation of loan obligations. (Since no outstanding liabilities remain, no rating will be assigned upon withdrawal, and the Rating Rationale will state the reasons for withdrawal).
  • When rated facilities are taken over by other banks, upon receipt of an NDC from the existing bank certifying that loans have been taken over and liabilities with them are NIL. (As obligations are fully extinguished, the rating will be withdrawn without assigning a new rating, and a press release will be published and shared with the client and their bankers).
  • For proposed bank loan facilities, upon obtaining an undertaking from the entity confirming that the rating has not been used for raising any loan and that no amount is outstanding against the facility (subject to additional verification as required).

8. Withdrawal of ratings for Issuer Ratings

(Ratings not specific to any particular debt obligation)

Issuer Ratings may be withdrawn under the following conditions:

  • If a mandate for surveillance is not received after the 12-month validity period, a Notice of Withdrawal will be served on the issuer. If no response is received within 15 days, the notice will be published on the website; after 3 months without valid objections, the rating will be withdrawn based on available information. (Any objections received will be referred to the issuer and dealt with appropriately).
  • If an issuer formally requests withdrawal during the validity period or during the notice period, the process will proceed immediately without placing the rating on (or completing) the Notice of Withdrawal period.

Note: In line with regulatory guidelines, a suitable press release will be issued upon withdrawal, declaring the rating assigned based on available information at the time of withdrawal.

9. Withdrawal of ratings for pooled investment schemes

(Mutual fund schemes [open/closed-ended], Alternative Investment Funds [AIFs, open/closed-ended], and capital protection-oriented schemes)

Ratings for pooled investment schemes may be withdrawn under the following conditions:

  • For perpetual or open-ended schemes (having no specified maturity), upon receipt of a written withdrawal request from the Asset Management Company (AMC). The rating will be placed on a 30-day Notice of Withdrawal on the website; if no objections are raised, the rating will be withdrawn. (Any objections received will be referred to the AMC and dealt with appropriately).
  • For closed-ended schemes, upon scheme maturity and full redemption of units, verified through written confirmation from the AMC and redemption details on the sponsor/third-party website.

Note: Upon withdrawal of an open-ended scheme's rating, BWR will assign a rating based on available information and issue a press release stating the reasons and assigned rating.

10. Withdrawal of ratings for Security Receipts (SRs)

Ratings for Security Receipts may be withdrawn under any of the following conditions:

  • Upon full redemption or provision of the Security Receipts, based on written confirmation from the Trustee (typically the Asset Reconstruction Company that created the trust for the stressed asset).
  • Upon expiration of the trust validity/tenor (5 years from formation, or up to 8 years if formally extended), based on an application from the trustee requesting withdrawal due to expiration of validity.
  • Prior to full redemption, upon receipt of NOCs from all investors or a written request from the trustee accompanied by an undertaking confirming that an alternate rating is available from another CRA.

11. Withdrawal of ratings for Expected Loss Rating

(Operational infrastructure assets)

Ratings for Expected Loss Rating on operational infrastructure assets may be withdrawn under the following conditions:

  • Upon receipt of a written request for withdrawal from the rated entity.
  • The rating will be placed on a Notice of Withdrawal for at least 1 month on the website prior to being withdrawn at the end of the notice period.

12. Withdrawal of ratings for Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) and Government Bodies

(One-time rating exercises with pre-specified validity periods)

Ratings assigned for one-time rating exercises (such as Urban Local Bodies, Municipal Corporations, or Government Bodies) may be withdrawn under the following conditions:

  • Upon expiration of the pre-specified validity period of the assigned rating(s).
  • Upon receipt of a formal withdrawal request from the entity or issuing authority at the end of the validity period.

Note: The procedure for processing and communicating the withdrawal of ULB and Government Body ratings follows the same protocol as Issuer Ratings (Section 8).

13. Withdrawal of ratings for Provisional Ratings

Initial assignments of provisional ratings may be withdrawn under any of the following conditions:

  • If material changes occur in transaction terms before the debt instrument is issued, the provisional rating will be withdrawn, citing the term modifications as the reason for withdrawal.
  • If material changes occur in transaction terms after debt issuance (for the issued portion), the existing provisional rating will be withdrawn and a fresh rating concurrently assigned based on revised terms via the same rating rationale.
  • If documentation remains incomplete and no debt is issued within 90 days of initial rating assignment, up to another 90-day extension (maximum 180 days total) may be granted upon specific written requests from the issuer; if debt remains unissued after these extensions, the rating will be withdrawn.
  • In the absence of a written request for extension from the issuer after 90 days, the rating will be placed on a 15-day Notice of Withdrawal on the website prior to withdrawal.
  • If the entity formally informs BWR that it does not intend to issue the proposed debt instrument or avail the proposed borrowing, and confirms non-usage of the provisional rating elsewhere, the rating will be withdrawn immediately.

Note: For further details, please refer to the Policy on Provisional Ratings available on the website.

14. Withdrawal of ratings in cases of corporate restructuring, insolvency, or legal dissolution

(Mergers, amalgamations, bankruptcy, IBC process through NCLT, management takeovers, winding up, or liquidation)

Ratings assigned to entities undergoing corporate restructuring, insolvency, or legal dissolution may be withdrawn under the following scenarios:

Scenario 1: Official request received from the entity/fund/scheme

Withdrawal will proceed after verifying the following:

  • The entity no longer has legal existence.
  • Final bankruptcy or court orders for liquidation/winding-up have been issued and submitted to BWR without pending appeals.
  • A copy of the court or statutory liquidation/winding-up order is available.
  • Bank NOCs/NDCs have been submitted. (In management takeovers, stock exchange filings, NCLT orders, or MCA website records may be relied upon to confirm management changes and liability status).

Scenario 2: No official request received

Withdrawal will proceed subject to the following:

  • Analytical verification confirms through MCA/ROC records that the entity no longer legally exists (wound up, liquidated, or amalgamated) and valid orders are available.
  • Entity status is listed as "STRIKE OFF" on the official MCA website (with official Gazette notifications recorded). (For management takeovers without debt redemption or legal extinguishment, ratings cannot be withdrawn solely based on management change without lender NOCs/NDCs or court orders).

General Rules for Corporate Restructuring and Insolvency Cases

  • External investigation agency clearances must be verified as of the withdrawal date; if an investigation notice exists, withdrawal proceeds only after conclusion and issuance of an official clearance letter.
  • For entities rated 'D' under INC where the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) is complete and an NCLT-approved Resolution Plan is implemented, ratings may be withdrawn once documentary evidence (bank statements, written confirmation from lenders or the Resolution Professional, and/or ROC satisfaction of charges) confirms full payment to existing lenders. (Approval from BD/MIS or fresh lender NOCs/NDCs is not mandatory in this specific scenario, and the same process applies to management takeovers through other legal mechanisms).
  • Until settlement amounts are fully disbursed, loan/security obligations remain active under Section 16(3) of CRA Regulations.
  • A fresh rating may be issued upon request from the new entity or new management based on the approved Resolution Plan.

15. Other indicative cases for withdrawing ratings

Ratings may be withdrawn under other specific circumstances according to the following guidelines:

  • Proposed Securities: Upon receipt of a written withdrawal request accompanied by an undertaking from the entity confirming that the BWR rating was not used to raise funds and that no amount remains outstanding against the proposed security.
  • Third-Party Credit Support Amendments: If explicit credit support or structural features become redundant, unavailable, or amended, BWR may withdraw the rating and concurrently assign a fresh rating based on the revised terms and circumstances via the same rating rationale.
  • General Communication Standard: For all withdrawal scenarios, a rating rationale / press release will be published on BWR’s website, and an official withdrawal letter will be issued to the client/issuer.

16. Withdrawal of Credit Enhanced Bank Loan Ratings (Bank Loan CE ratings)

Credit-Enhanced (CE) ratings, including entities currently classified under Issuer Not Cooperating (INC) or Rating Not Reviewed (RNR), may be withdrawn under any of the following circumstances:

  • Standard Loan Closure: Upon receipt of a written withdrawal request from the entity accompanied by a No Dues Certificate (NDC) from all lending banks.
  • Corporate Restructuring or Dissolution: Upon receipt of an official dissolution order, National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) order, court order, merger/amalgamation document, Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) strike-off notification, or Gazette notification, following the procedure in Clause 14 of this policy.
  • Termination or Modification of Credit Enhancement: When the underlying credit enhancement is legally revoked, modified, or terminated. In such cases, BWR will withdraw the CE rating, simultaneously assign a standalone (unsupported) rating based on the revised terms, and publish the rating rationale on BWR’s website.
  • Premature Lapse or Event of Default: When the credit enhancement lapses prematurely or an adverse event occurs without lender consent. BWR will evaluate default risk on a standalone basis and may downgrade the rating, place it on "Rating Watch," or issue a "Notice of Withdrawal" prior to finalizing the withdrawal.
  • Lender Consent: Upon receipt of written confirmation from the lending bank(s) stating that credit enhancement obligations have been fully satisfied or consenting to the withdrawal of the rating and its underlying structure.

Prior to executing any withdrawal across the scenarios above, BWR shall place a Rating note before the respective Rating Committee to assign an applicable rating and proceed with the withdrawal. (assignment of rating not applicable where the closure is supported by NDC (No Due Certificate).

If no information is furnished by the client, after making withdrawal request, BWR shall withdraw the rating while simultaneously assigning the rating under Issuer Not Cooperating (INC) rating.

17. Withdrawal of ratings for Securitised Debt Instruments (SDIs)

This policy applies to all tranches (Senior, Mezzanine, and Junior) of listed or proposed-to-be-listed Securitised Debt Instruments and structured finance instruments backed by pool receivables across all scenarios (including issuer requests, clean-up calls, full amortization, mergers, or non-cooperation). Ratings will not be withdrawn while obligations remain outstanding except in accordance with SEBI-specified norms.

Permissible Grounds for Withdrawal

Ratings for SDIs may be withdrawn under any of the following circumstances:

  • Upon full redemption or maturity, when all obligations are fully discharged, supported by confirmation from the Trustee, Issuer/SPV, or Debenture Trustee along with documentary evidence of redemption.
  • Upon exercise of a contractual clean-up call by the originator/servicer once the outstanding pool balance falls below the specified threshold, supported by trustee confirmation and legal proof of investor obligation extinguishment.
  • For multiple rating scenarios where multiple ratings are not mandatory, provided minimum continuous rating periods (e.g., 3 years or 50% of tenure) are met, NOCs from at least 75% of investors by value are obtained, an issuer undertaking confirms an alternate rating, and confirmation is received from the other CRA.
  • For single rating scenarios, provided minimum continuous rating periods (e.g., 5 years or 50% of tenure) are met, an alternate rating is obtained from another SEBI-registered CRA, and appropriate issuer undertakings and CRA confirmations are secured.
  • Upon merger or legal dissolution of the SPV following full discharge of obligations, supported by legal and trustee confirmations.

Documentation Required

  • Trustee confirmation letter, redemption certificate, clean-up call notice, investor NOCs (where applicable), issuer undertaking regarding alternate rating availability, and confirmation from the alternate CRA.

Analytical Review Requirements

  • Verification that no outstanding investor exposure, pending structured obligations, credit events, or residual credit enhancement liabilities exist.
  • Confirmation of tranche-level obligation discharge, waterfall termination, concluded service obligations, and the absence of deferred payouts.

Disclosures and Stock Exchange Intimation

  • If obligations are outstanding at withdrawal, BWR will assign a rating at withdrawal, publish a press release stating the reason for withdrawal, outstanding position, and alternate rating details on the website, notify stock exchange(s) if listed, and comply with SEBI listing disclosure requirements. (No press release is required if obligations are fully extinguished, subject to prevailing SEBI norms).

Version History Effective date Link
1.0 March 2019 Policy for Rating Withdrawal
2.0 January 2020 Policy for Rating Withdrawal
3.0 April 2020 Policy for Rating Withdrawal
4.0 September 2020 Policy for Rating Withdrawal
5.0 January 2021 Policy for Rating Withdrawal
6.0 September 2021 Policy for Rating Withdrawal
7.0 February 2022 Policy for Rating Withdrawal
8.0 September 2022 Policy for Rating Withdrawal
9.0 December 2022 Policy for Rating Withdrawal
10.0 June 2026 Policy for Rating Withdrawal
11.0 November 2026