Skip to main content

Policy on Issuer Non-Cooperation

October 2026

1. Objective

Effective credit assessment and continuous surveillance depend on access to timely, adequate, and reliable information from rated entities. In the absence of requisite data, evaluating creditworthiness involves significant information adequacy risk. In line with SEBI’s Master Circular for Credit Rating Agencies and operational circular SEBI/HO/DDHS/DDHS-POD2/P/CIR/2025/101 dated July 11, 2025, this policy establishes the framework governing surveillance, rating actions, migrations, and disclosures when an issuer fails to cooperate.

2. Surveillance Review Timelines

BWR monitors all assigned ratings throughout an instruments or facility’s life cycle, adhering to the following review timelines:

a) Capital Market Instruments (NCDs, Bonds, Commercial Paper): Reviews must be concluded within 12 months from the date of publication of the previous Press Release / Rating Rationale.

b) Bank Loan Ratings (BLR): Reviews must be completed within 12 months, but not later than 15 months from the date of publication of the previous Press Release / Rating Rationale.

c) Listing Under "Rating Not Reviewed": If a review cannot be concluded by the due date due to lack of cooperation or essential information, the entity shall be placed under the "Rating Not Reviewed" section on BWR’s website on the next working day following the due date as per the following table:

Company name Instrument/facility rated Issue size (in Rs. crores) Last reviewed date and Rationale Reason for delay

3. What Constitutes Issuer Non-Cooperation (INC)

BWR outlines the indicative information required to assign and monitor credit ratings on its website (for details, refer to the Policy on Indicative Information Requirement). Even where an issuer fails to provide this required information, defaults on surveillance fees, or omits monthly No Default Statements (NDS), BWR is mandated to continue surveillance on a best-effort basis using available public and third-party information, explicitly factoring in information adequacy risk.

An issuer/borrower shall be categorized under "Issuer Not Cooperating" (INC) upon the occurrence of any of the following:

a) Failure to Provide Information or Clarifications: Refusing or failing to provide information or clarifications required for periodic reviews and ongoing surveillance.

b) Failure to Report Material Developments: Failing to notify BWR of events, operational changes, or financial developments that affect business performance, financial stability, or corporate structure, and have a bearing on the assigned rating.

c) Non-Submission of Operational and Financial Disclosures: Failing to submit required disclosures within prescribed timelines, including:

  • Quarterly, half-yearly, or audited annual financial statements.
  • Historical and current operational metrics, including ongoing and planned capital expenditures.
  • Debt profiles, borrowing arrangements, and repayment schedules.
  • Information required under BWR’s Rating Process Manual (RPM) or internal credit policies.

d) Failure to Respond to Debt Servicing and Default Queries: Failing to confirm debt servicing status, delays, or defaults within two (2) working days of BWR seeking clarification following feedback from Debenture Trustees (DTs), lenders, Issuing and Paying Agents (IPAs), or public sources.

e) Non-Payment of Surveillance Fees: Failing to pay agreed surveillance fees as stipulated in the Rating Agreement.

f) Non-Submission of No Default Statement (NDS): Failing to submit the monthly NDS for three (3) consecutive months, where BWR cannot independently verify timely debt servicing through lenders, DTs, or other sources.

  • In such cases, the analytical team shall submit a note to the Rating Committee within five (5) working days from the end of the third month recommending migration to INC.
  • BWR reserves the right to migrate an entity to INC prior to three months if available information indicates heightened credit risk.

Upon migrating an issuer/borrower to the INC category:

  • The rating symbol shall carry the suffix "ISSUER NOT COOPERATING" in the same font size (e.g., BWR BB (ISSUER NOT COOPERATING)).
  • The press release and rating rationale shall include the following statement: "Issuer did not cooperate; based on best available information."

4. Rating Actions under INC

In the absence of adequate information, BWR assesses creditworthiness using available public data and third-party feedback, applying the rating actions outlined below:

Scenario Rating Action Press Release / Disclosure Requirement
Partial or no information provided, with no clear evidence of credit deterioration. Reviewed on best available information (lender/DT/IPA feedback, NDS, public domain). The rating may be reaffirmed or adjusted based on assessment. Highlight analytical limitations; state that the rating does not adequately reflect the credit risk profile due to information inadequacy.
Partial or no information provided, and available information indicates credit deterioration since the last review. The rating shall be downgraded. The notch adjustment will correspond to the estimated extent of credit deterioration. Disclose specific factors driving the downgrade, analytical constraints, and the lack of issuer cooperation.
Persistent non-cooperation for more than 6 months for an issuer with an Investment Grade rating.* The rating shall be downgraded to Non-Investment Grade (BWR BB+ or lower), retaining the ISSUER NOT COOPERATING status. Specify that the downgrade is mandated due to prolonged non-cooperation exceeding six months under regulatory norms.
Evidence of default obtained via lenders, Debenture Trustees, IPAs, investors, or public sources. Immediate downgrade to the Default category (BWR D (ISSUER NOT COOPERATING)) per BWR’s Default Recognition Policy. Prompt publication of a Default Press Release detailing the nature of the default and source of confirmation

*Note: Mandatory downgrade to Non-Investment Grade applies when an Investment Grade issuer has all outstanding ratings categorized as non-cooperative for more than six (6) months. However, BWR reserves the right to downgrade the rating earlier based on credit risk assessment and available information.

Suo Moto Rating Actions

While an entity remains in the INC category, BWR reserves the right to take suo moto rating actions based on available material price-sensitive information, regulatory enforcement, judicial orders, or significant market developments.

5. Rating Entities Non-Cooperative with Other CRAs

Before accepting a fresh rating assignment or facility enhancement, BWR verifies the issuer's cooperation status with other Credit Rating Agencies (CRAs). Where an issuer has existing ratings under the "Issuer Not Cooperating" (INC) status with other CRAs (referred to as CRA 1 and CRA 2), BWR applies the following decision matrix:

Sl. No. Scenario Overview Status with CRA 1 Status with CRA 2 BWR Policy / Assignment Rule
1 INC with all CRAs for 12 months or more INC for 12 months or more INC for 12 months or more Barred. BWR shall not accept the assignment or assign a rating until the issuer resumes cooperation with at least one CRA, or the INC ratings are formally withdrawn by all previous agencies under regulatory guidelines.
2 INC with one CRA for 12+ months, but less than 12 months with the second CRA INC for 12 months or more INC for less than 12 months Permitted with time limit. BWR may accept the assignment and publish the rating rationale within 12 months from the date the entity became INC with CRA 2. If BWR cannot conclude the assessment and publish the rationale within this 12-month window, BWR shall not proceed with the publication.
3 INC with one CRA, but actively cooperating with another CRA INC for 12 months or more Cooperating with CRA 2 (Not INC) Permitted. Because the issuer is actively cooperating with at least one CRA, BWR can accept the assignment and assign a rating.
4 INC with both CRAs for less than 12 months INC for less than 12 months INC for less than 12 months Permitted with time limit. BWR may assign a rating and publish the press release within 12 months from the later of the two dates on which the entity was categorized as INC by CRA 1 or CRA 2.

The rules in the table above are subject to the following exceptions:

a) In the case of securities (NCDs, Bonds, and other capital market instruments), BWR shall not accept a fresh rating assignment if the issuer is non-cooperative with other CRAs, unless:

  • The issuer resumes active cooperation with CRA 1 or CRA 2; or
  • The issuer provides verifiable documentary evidence of having submitted a formal withdrawal request to both CRA 1 and CRA 2 (duly acknowledged by them), and the ratings are eligible for withdrawal under SEBI guidelines.

b) If BWR already maintains an outstanding rating for an entity that subsequently becomes non-cooperative with other CRAs, BWR will continue its surveillance on existing facilities and may assign ratings to enhanced limits or new programs, irrespective of the issuer’s INC status with other CRAs.

6. Resumption of Cooperation

If an issuer categorized under INC subsequently submits the requisite surveillance mandate, past financial statements, future business projections, and regularized No Default Statements (NDS), a comprehensive rating review shall be conducted to restore standard rating surveillance and remove the INC suffix.

7. Disclosures on Website for INC Ratings

a) Information to be Disclosed in the Press Release / Rating Rationale:

Rating actions concerning INC entities shall be promptly disclosed through a Rating Rationale / Press Release published on the BWR website in accordance with SEBI formats. Each Rating Rationale / Press Release shall disclose, at least, the following particulars:

• Date of Publication: Date of the Press Release / Rating Rationale.

• Instrument Details: Complete details of the rated security or borrowing facility.

• Rating Action & Symbol Suffix: Rating action and the updated/indicative rating symbol, carrying the mandatory suffix "ISSUER NOT COOPERATING" in the same font size (e.g., BWR BB (ISSUER NOT COOPERATING)).

• Mandatory Standard Statement: The prominent inclusion of the standard declaration: "Issuer did not cooperate; based on best available information."

• Non-Cooperation Narrative & Audit Trail: A brief write-up describing the nature of the issuer’s non-cooperation alongside details of the continuous, consistent follow-ups carried out by BWR to obtain the requisite information.

• Information Adequacy Disclosure & Caveat: Specific narrative highlighting analytical limitations and incorporating a suitable caveat cautioning investors, lenders, and market participants that the rating does not adequately reflect the credit risk profile due to lack of adequate information and co-operation from the issuer.

• Criteria References: Hyperlinks and references to all applicable BWR Rating Criteria and Methodologies.

• Rating History: Comprehensive rating history of the instrument/facility for the preceding three (3) years.

• Analyst Contacts: Name and contact details of the primary rating analysts.

• Prior Non-Cooperation with Other CRAs:In case an entity that previously failed to cooperate with another Credit Rating Agency approaches BWR for a rating assignment, BWR shall explicitly disclose this past non-cooperation.

b) List of Non-Cooperative Issuers

BWR shall maintain two separate lists on its website:

• Securities that are listed, or proposed to be listed, on a recognized stock exchange.

• Other ratings (including unlisted debt and Bank Loan Ratings).

These lists shall be updated on the BWR website on a daily basis in the following format:

Sl. No. Name of the Non-Cooperative Issuer Date of Categorization as Non-Cooperative Reason for Issuer Non-Cooperation Link to the Webpage Hosting the Issuer’s Press Release
1 [Issuer Name] [DD/MM/YYYY] [Non-submission of NDS / Non-furnishing of financials / Non-payment of surveillance fees / Lack of response to queries] [Hyperlink to Rationale / Press Release]
2 [Issuer Name] [DD/MM/YYYY] [Non-submission of NDS / Non-furnishing of financials / Non-payment of surveillance fees / Lack of response to queries] [Hyperlink to Rationale / Press Release]

Version History Effective date Link
1.0 March 2019 Policy On Issuer Non Co-operation
2.0 January 2020 Policy On Issuer Non Co-operation
3.0 April 2020 Policy On Issuer Non Co-operation
4.0 September 2020 Policy On Issuer Non Co-operations
5.0 January 2021 Policy On Issuer Non Co-operation
6.0 July 2022 Policy On Issuer Non Co-operation
7.0 March 2023 Policy On Issuer Non Co-operation
8.0 January 2025 Policy On Issuer Non Co-operation
9.0 October 2026